GoHotelly

The Eldred Preserve

Experience The Eldred Preserve, a 4.4-star resort hotel in Eldred, NY. Enjoy top-rated dining, wedding venue services, and a peaceful getaway. Book now.

1040 State Rte 55, Eldred, NY 12732, United States View on map
8.8/10
Very Good Based on 231 recent guest reviews
What recent guests emphasize

The Eldred Preserve

This resort hotel is highly regarded for its scenic natural setting, attentive staff, and excellent dining experiences. Guests consistently highlight the peaceful environment and the resort’s suitability for weddings and relaxing getaways.

Guests often praise

  • Luxurious accommodations featuring heated floors, jacuzzi tubs, fireplaces, and impressive views.
  • Exceptionally friendly, attentive, and accommodating staff, often going above and beyond to meet guest needs.
  • Outstanding dining options including delicious breakfasts and customizable menus praised especially for weddings.
  • Beautiful, well-kept grounds with walking trails, lakeside views, and activities such as snowshoeing and kayaking.
  • Seamless and professional wedding planning support with flexible event spaces and detailed attention to logistics.

Worth knowing

  • There may be occasional small issues at check-in, but staff responsiveness and care help resolve them quickly.
  • The on-site restaurant currently does not serve lunch and is not open every day, which can limit dining options without leaving the property.
  • While very scenic, the surrounding area offers limited dining or entertainment choices outside the resort.
  • The property excels as an intimate venue, with best results when booking and planning sufficiently in advance.

Best for

  • Couples or groups seeking a picturesque and tranquil setting for weddings or special events.
  • Travelers desiring a high-end nature retreat with luxurious, comfortable lodging and beautiful outdoor spaces.
  • Guests who appreciate personalized service and high-quality dining with an emphasis on accommodating dietary needs.
  • Visitors looking for a peaceful getaway featuring activities like lakeside walks, snowshoeing, and outdoor relaxation.
Compare booking partners

Open this hotel on the platform you trust.

GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.

Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.

About this property

Welcome to The Eldred Preserve

Nestled in the scenic surroundings of Eldred, NY, The Eldred Preserve offers a blend of resort hotel comforts with natural charm. This property features well-appointed accommodations, including boutique hotel options like The Bradstan Boutique Hotel, praised for its modern touches and tranquil setting. Guests often highlight the picturesque grounds with a serene lake, well-maintained walking paths, and peaceful spots ideal for reflection or outdoor activities such as snowshoeing.

The resort provides several amenities tailored to its diverse offerings as both a restaurant and wedding venue. Dining experiences consistently receive high marks, with guests noting a varied and accommodating breakfast selection and a welcoming on-site restaurant. While there are suggestions for expanding dining hours to better meet guest needs, the current service maintains a reputation for friendliness and quality.

Widely regarded as a distinctive location for weddings, the property boasts extensive event spaces, including outdoor areas like the heated Pergola and a nearby fire pit for welcome parties or rehearsal dinners. Numerous couples have praised the attentive and professional event staff, emphasizing the smooth coordination and customization that contribute to memorable celebrations.

Positioned in a tranquil area with limited local dining options, The Eldred Preserve appeals especially to visitors seeking a peaceful lakefront retreat with high-end amenities. The combination of natural beauty, well-kept facilities, and thoughtful service attracts guests looking for a refined getaway or a special event venue in a scenic, rural setting.

Summary compiled by GoHotelly editors from verified guest reviews, partner descriptions and editorial notes.
Verified guest reviews

What recent guests are actually saying

Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.

MC
marc c Apr 15, 2026
10

What a spectacular place on so many levels! Our “cabin” was as luxurious as one can get with high end everything including heated floors, jacuzzi tub, gas fireplace, and a wall of glass overlooking the snow covered woods. The breakfast included was amazingly delicious and diverse with the 2 lovely kitchen staff going above and beyond to offer me gluten free options such as a decadent chocolate brownie, muffins and French toast. Dinner at their Homestead restaurant was a treat also. To top it all off, the acres of grounds were beautiful to behold. My husband and I snowshoed around their lake which was peaceful and fun. They provided the snowshoes. This weekend vacation at the Eldred Preserve was possibly our best weekend getaway ever! And we have had many! Bravo and well done to everyone there!

KD
Kate Deyermond Mar 30, 2026
10

We had such a pleasant stay at this beautiful resort. We love being able to stroll around the lake, it’s truly one of our favorite parts of staying here. Having an on-site restaurant is wonderful, the happy hour is great, and the breakfast is absolutely amazing. The staff is always so kind and welcoming. While there was a small mix-up with our room at check-in, the way the team handled it really stood out. They were genuinely apologetic, showed true integrity and care. We appreciate how quickly everything was resolved and how comfortable they made us for the rest of our stay.

VT
Vu Tran Mar 15, 2026
10

Amazing place. You couldn't ask for a more scenic place set in nature for you to have a wedding venue. From the babbling brook to the surrounding ponds its amazing here. The food was great and the staff so nice. Everything feels nice and up to date. Not like some of the usual out dated wedding halls.

KS
Kyle Stafford Mar 10, 2026
10

The food was amazing and staff was very friendly. The service was great and the place is beautiful. I’ve been there numerous times before and plan on going back. I would highly recommend to anyone to go and eat there.

KL
Krystal L Mar 04, 2026
10

If you are looking for a getaway that perfectly balances serenity and activity, the Eldred Preserve is it. The grounds are impeccably kept, offering peaceful nooks for quiet reflection alongside a stunning lakeside trail for a scenic hike. The service was the definition of "above and beyond." Curtis and his incredible team made our entire party feel like VIPs, ensuring that every need was met before we even had to ask. I was also thoroughly impressed by the dining experience. It is clear the management took past feedback to heart, as the food quality has reached a whole new level. This is a true destination for anyone seeking a polished, high-end retreat

AM
Ashley Miller Feb 11, 2026
10

We recently had our wedding at The Eldred Preserve, and it was truly the best day of our lives. We couldn’t have been happier with how everything turned out. From the very beginning, Curtis and Matt were incredible—warm, accommodating, and completely on top of every detail. Their care and professionalism made the entire planning process seamless. We toured several local venues, but nothing compared to The Eldred. The setting is stunning, the property is spotless, and every staff member we interacted with was wonderful. We were able to take so many beautiful photos in a variety of locations around the property — everywhere you turn is a perfect backdrop. Our hotel room was beautiful, and the food was outstanding. We were even able to customize our menu, and it turned out exactly the way we envisioned. We planned our small wedding (25 people) in just about two months, and thanks to Curtis and Matt, it was stress‑free. Our guests were blown away by the venue and couldn’t stop talking about how delicious the food was. We truly had an amazing day. If you’re looking for a picture‑perfect wedding and a team of people who genuinely care about making it unforgettable, look no further than The Eldred Preserve.

DP
David Press Feb 09, 2026
10

Bradstan Resort and Eldred Preserve were fabulous, as was the Homestead Restaurant. My "criticism" is that they should also serve lunch and that the restaurant should be open all 7 days of the week. Hotel guests should not have to leave the grounds. A lot of the area restaurants also closed mid-week, and the surrounding area is not so great, in my opinion.

VN
Victoria Novak Jan 16, 2026
10

We had our wedding at the Eldred Preserve in October 2025 and it was truly the best day ever! Matt & Curtis are the dream team and made sure our day was perfect. They went above and beyond to make our vision come to life. They were very responsive to all of our emails and were always willing to hop on a call to discuss the details as we were planning. One thing we were worried about was the space in the reception room because we had a 10 piece band and we were at the higher end of the guest count. Matt was able to create multiple floor plan options for us to review and the space set up was perfect. The food was honestly some of the best wedding food we have ever had. The Eldred Preserve grounds are stunning and the hotel is gorgeous. My guests could not believe how beautiful the place was. There is a big lake in the back where we were chauffeured around in a golf cart to take some of our wedding photos. Our guests also enjoyed the lake where they could kayak, walk around the paths, paddle boat and more. The breakfast in the morning is also delicious. Irvin, who runs the hotel, was amazing and worked with us to make sure all of our guests were able to get rooms. The Eldred Preserve is a one stop shop for a wedding and has everything you could possibly imagine to complete your wedding day. We also had our rehearsal dinner/welcome party the night before at the Pergola which is also one of their many nice event spaces. The pergola is outdoors, but has heaters. We were very comfortable on a chilly October night under the pergola. There is also a fire pit nearby that my guests very much enjoyed during our welcome party. Overall, I could not imagine a more perfect venue for our special day.

Location & neighborhood

Where you'll find The Eldred Preserve

People also viewed

Similar Resort Hotels in New York

Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.

520 W 1st St, Hereford, TX 79045, United States

Relax Inn ( Extended Stay )

Relax Inn ( Extended Stay ) offers comfortable extended stay motel accommodations in Hereford, TX with free WiFi, parking, kitche...

3.8 (43) View
32423 M-26, Toivola, MI 49965, United States

Parkview Lodge & Grill

Comfortable Parkview Lodge & Grill offers free WiFi, indoor pool, and grill restaurant near Twin Lakes State Park in Toivola, MI....

4.4 (298) View
4040 11th Ave S, Grand Forks, ND 58201, United States

Grand Forks Lodge

Stay at Grand Forks Lodge, a 4.1star hotel offering free WiFi, indoor pool, and breakfast. Near Splashers Water Park and North D...

4.1 (455) View
405 Española Wy, Miami Beach, FL 33139, United States

Kasa El Paseo Miami Beach

Stay at Kasa El Paseo Miami Beach with stylish rooms, free drinks, LGBTQ+ friendly service, close to nightlife, art deco sights, a...

4.5 (1,331) View
2431 3rd Ave W, Dickinson, ND 58601, United States

My Place Hotel-Dickinson, ND

Stay at My Place HotelDickinson, ND featuring modern rooms, kitchenettes, free WiFi, 24/7 convenience store, and free parking. Ne...

4.3 (193) View
16427 S Western Ave, Gardena, CA 90247, United States

Nisei Inn

Nisei Inn offers cozy, traditional rooms with free WiFi, continental breakfast, and parking near Pacific Square Shopping Center i...

3 (350) View
626 Center St, Jim Thorpe, PA 18229, United States

Mountain View Suites

Stay at Mountain View Suites in Jim Thorpe, PA. Enjoy mountain views, free WiFi, free parking, and proximity to Asa Packer Mansio...

3.4 (98) View
Humpy Cove & Resurrection Bay, Seward, AK 99664, United States

Orca Island Cabins

Enjoy a 4.9star resort hotel stay at Orca Island Cabins in Seward, AK. LGBTQ+ friendly with top nearby attractions like Alaska Se...

4.9 (77) View
Share your stay

Stayed at The Eldred Preserve? Help the next traveler decide.

Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.

Your email is only used to verify the review — it won't be shown publicly.